How to Have an Old-Fashioned Christmas This Year
We like to put our Christmas tree up early around here. Part of the fun is turning on the tree lights on a regular old Tuesday, making a cup of tea, and having a little bit of Christmas even if there’s still a basket of laundry on the couch.
That’s the kind of old-fashioned Christmas I’m after. A paper chain that gets a little longer every evening. The good cookie recipe with the butter stain on it. A night when everybody stays at the table long enough to play another hand of cards.
If you’ve been wondering how to have an old-fashioned Christmas this year, start with an evening you already have at home. Pick one thing from this list, put on some Christmas music, and see who wanders into the kitchen.
1. Let the decorations go up a little at a time
I’m all for getting the tree up early. The rest can happen whenever you get to it. Hang a ribbon on the front door one weekend. Fill a basket with pinecones another. Give the kids the scrap paper and see how long a chain they can make before they run out of red.
If you want something that makes the house smell like Christmas, tuck a few evergreen clippings from your own yard into a jar and tie a ribbon around it. I’d set mine by the kitchen sink, where I’ll get to see it about fifty times a day.
For more ideas, try these old-fashioned Christmas decorations you can make from nature.

2. Pick one cookie recipe to make every December
There’s always a cookie someone looks for first. Maybe it’s a soft molasses cookie with a crackly sugar top, or a sugar cookie with enough frosting to slide right off the edge. Ours is always my no-bake oatmeal cookies, or like my youngest calls them “reindeer poop”. Pick one recipe you’d be happy to make again next year and write it on a card.
Give the kids a job they’ll actually want. One can roll the dough in sugar, one can pick the cookie cutters, and somebody can be in charge of counting out six cookies for a neighbor. Put a few aside for your own house before that last job starts.
Check out some of our favorite cookie recipes here!
3. Have a Christmas craft night at the kitchen table
Put out paper lunch bags, ribbon scraps, scissors, and glue. Pick one project everybody can work on at their own pace. Paper stars are a good one because you can hang the first finished star while everyone else is still working. Homemade gift tags are even easier. Cut them from the blank side of last year’s Christmas cards and let the kids decorate them.
Make cocoa, put on a Christmas album, and leave the supplies out until bedtime. Anyone who needs a break can go do something else and come back for another star later.
I’ve got more ideas and a simple supply list in How to Host an Old-Fashioned Christmas Craft Night.

4. Wrap a few gifts that give kids something to do
A set of dominoes gives them something to line up all the way down the hallway. A little rolling pin and a handwritten cookie recipe can turn into plans for Saturday morning. A used copy of a book you loved at their age makes a sweet gift with a note tucked inside.
If you’re shopping for siblings or cousins, consider one gift they can open together. Put a puzzle in the middle of the table on Christmas morning and see who keeps coming back to fit in just one more piece.
5. Make one rainy December evening worth staying in for
Here in the Pacific Northwest, there’s a decent chance the view out the window will be wet pavement and a porch light. That’s a good night to eat grilled cheese and tomato soup, turn on the tree lights, and deal a hand of Go Fish. Let the winner choose the next game. Let the person who comes in last pick the snack.
If your family would rather get out of the house, fill a thermos, grab your raincoats, and walk or drive around to look at lights. Have everyone pick their favorite house on the way home. There’s always someone voting for the one with the most stuff in the yard.

6. Drop something off for a neighbor
Bring over a few cookies, a jar of homemade cocoa mix, or a card the kids made. Let them write the message if they want. “I hope you have a good Christmas” is plenty, especially in big, wobbly handwriting.
You can do the same thing by mail. A printed photo with a couple of sentences about what your family’s been up to makes a lovely card for someone who lives far away. Leave a little room for the kids to draw in the corner.
7. Read the same Christmas story every year
Pick a book from the shelf or let everybody vote on one from the library. Read it by the tree on Christmas Eve, or on the last night before school lets out if Christmas Eve is already full. When the kids start saying a familiar line before you get to it, you’ll know you’ve found a keeper.
Our Christmas Eve read has always been The Night Before Christmas.
For more ideas you can bring back each December, see 10 Old-Fashioned Christmas Traditions to Start With Your Family.

8. Save one little piece of this Christmas
Write the year on an envelope and tuck in a photo, a recipe card, or a drawing somebody made while waiting for the cookies to come out. Add one line about what happened that day. “We played cards until the popcorn ran out” will bring the evening back better than trying to remember the whole month.
Put the envelope in the box with your ornaments. Next year you’ll find it right when the Christmas stuff comes down from the shelf.
A simple old-fashioned Christmas weekend
- Friday night — Make cocoa and cut strips for a paper chain while the tree lights are on.
- Saturday afternoon — Bake one batch of cookies and set a few aside to share.
- Sunday evening — Read a Christmas story or play cards after dinner.
If this weekend is already packed, pick the one you’d look forward to most and do it on a weeknight. I’d start with the cookies. Once the first tray comes out, people have a way of finding their way into the kitchen.
What’s one Christmas tradition you remember from growing up? Tell me in the comments, especially if it was something small your family did every year. And if you’re collecting ideas for December, save this post to your Christmas board so you can come back to it when the tree goes up.

